[This is Part 2 of the Navigating Political Speech series. Part 1 is here.]
The pressure to post politically is real. We’ve all felt it. If you’re an Indie-expert with an audience you’ve spent years building, when something in the world feels urgent, silence can feel like a failure of nerve.
But I’ve watched people lose readers they’d spent years earning over a post that felt urgent on Sunday and was forgotten a few days later.
You are always two people: the expert your audience hired, and the citizen you also happen to be. The pressure to post politically comes from blurring those lines.
Something is always happening in the world that feels urgent. And the question isn’t whether you have a view. It’s whether that view belongs on your professional feed — the one your clients and buyers read.
The reasons to post always sound logical. I’ve heard them all. What follows are the seven most common rationales experts give for blurring that line. Each one is sincere, and each one is worth examining before you hit publish.
Rationale 1: I Want to Change Minds
As Indie-experts, we’re often in the business of changing minds and are tasked with helping the student or client see the need to change and navigate those shifts.
The question that exposes this is simple: is this desire to change minds on the feed about the conditions of the work, or about some external scoreboard? If you’re honest, the feed usually turns out to be the scoreboard.
Trying to change the minds of strangers and people who may as well be strangers (followers) is vastly different from changing hearts and minds with readers and clients who’ve shown up specifically for that work with you.
Kevin Kelly said it well: “You can’t reason someone out of a notion they didn’t reason themselves into.” That’s the ceiling. The research shows what happens when people test it anyway.
The real issue with the sincere desire to “change minds” seems to be this: can one legitimately change anyone’s mind on social media?
What the Studies Show
Chris Bail’s field experiment, which paid Democrats and Republicans to follow bots that retweeted opposing elites, did not moderate either. Both sides became more hardened in their positions. Which is pretty much the polar opposite of that nice civics-class lesson about “just put the truth out there.”
Facebook actually tested this during the 2020 election. They cut the partisan echo chamber by a third. People saw more of the other side. Incivility dropped slightly. No measured opinion shifted – not on candidates, not on policy, not on what people believed was true.
A 2026 paper on “false polarization” is even more useful here. Strong ideologues post more than moderates. Extreme attitudes get posted more than moderate ones. Posted opinions are more hostile than privately held ones.
Online discourse looks more polarized than the population it claims to represent because of self-selection, not because platforms magically radicalized everyone.
The person advocating is disproportionately also the person who already has a tribe. The audience they reach is disproportionately the same tribe, plus the opposing tribe’s scouts (or bots) looking for a fight.
Rationale 2: My Voice Could Tip the Scales
A client once told me he felt he had to keep posting political content online because his voice could contribute to a “butterfly effect” of social proof. If enough people posted, he reasoned, it would eventually produce a wave too large for “everyone else” to ignore.
This sincere belief stems from a misunderstanding of how social media and the illusion of online consensus work.
Every time a topic floods a social feed, people treat that volume as proof of a real shift. A few thousand posts suddenly appear, all pointing in the same direction; replies pile up, and it starts to feel like “the public” has moved.
The catch is that most of that volume never reaches the people who would actually have to change their minds for any broader consensus to form.
The Funhouse-Mirror Effect
Researchers at NYU call this the funhouse-mirror effect. On social platforms, a small number of highly active accounts dominate what anyone sees.
One paper found that 3% of active accounts produce 33% of all content, and that roughly 10% of users generate 97% of political posts. What’s more, a good portion of that 10% are either bots or paid posters.
Most of us sit in the silent majority that distribution never counts – people who hold ordinary views and post rarely or never. Our voices barely register. When the feed fills with that vocal 10%, the quieter majority looks far smaller than it actually is.
Algorithms make this distortion worse by ranking for heat and noise. A bot can flood a feed with ten thousand posts on a topic and get the replies stacking up — but that volume stays inside the bubble of people who’ve already agreed.
That is why the “enough voices” strategy rarely converts anyone outside the relevant bubble. The same ranking systems that amplify the posts also limit who sees them. A person who has never clicked on the topic sees little or none of the cascade. The appearance of a throng is very real for the people already inside the conversation, and largely absent for everyone else.
As the Facebook study I mentioned above pointed out, the bubble shapes what feels normal inside it. It does little to rewrite what people on the outside believe.
Much of What You See is Bought and Paid For
The bigger problem is when money enters the picture — paid campaigns stack enough early posts that the platform starts ranking the topic as if ordinary people suddenly care.
Recent reporting on the U.S. midterms documented networks of paid creators – sometimes paid per post, sometimes by the day – producing high-volume video and commentary on specific topics so that the platforms begin treating the subject as something many ordinary accounts are discussing.
One analysis of 2026 candidate conversation found roughly one in nine posts originating from inauthentic accounts, with even higher rates in the comments.
Here’s what’s important for our conversation: The goal of these paid opps is not to convert the other side, because they know how the algorithms work. It’s to make a claim look unavoidable inside the relevant bubble – so that people who already agree treat the volume itself as evidence they’re on the right side, which makes it harder for the other side to sway their opinions.
AI has only made this manipulation harder to catch. The old tells were obvious — identical bot comments posted seconds apart. Now a single prompt can generate a hundred variations of the same reply, each one worded differently, each one landing in the feed looking like a separate person who happened to show up.
The platform sees volume and variety and ranks it up. It doesn’t matter whether the original claim is even true. What matters is that the posts arrive in a coordinated wave and the algorithm treats them as if they came from real people, independently, all at once.
The Platform Controls the Water
If you’ve made a deliberate choice to stay out of political conversations online, this is one more good reason to trust that instinct. Stay in your expertise lane — health, family, craft, whatever your work is actually about — and let the paid campaigns do their thing inside someone else’s bubble.
I love the way Jonathan Pageau frames this: you don’t change minds unless you first change the water in which the fish are swimming. On social media, no poster controls “the water.” The platform does. And the platform is optimized to keep the fish reactive, which is precisely what all of the above confirms.
The paid campaigns are only part of it. The feed isn’t a neutral carrier for your message — by choosing how and where to show your posts, it effectively edits you.
When The Feed Edits You
The same post that reads as measured in your head arrives in someone else’s feed after an algorithm has ranked it for engagement.
Picture a naturopath who posts a carefully written thread about food policy and metabolic disease.
She spends a paragraph noting exactly what she is not claiming — that medications don’t work, that the whole system is corrupt.
She posts it on a Friday morning and goes back to work.
By afternoon, the algorithm has shown it in a heated thread about a federal food policy fight. The reader who clicks through has just spent an hour arguing. They skim her opening qualifier, land on the paragraph that leads with the problem, and decide what she is.
By evening, she’s being quoted in a reply thread she never saw — as proof of a position she explicitly said she wasn’t taking.
She didn’t get hacked. No one misquoted her. The words were hers. But the platform delivered those words inside a context she didn’t choose, next to a conversation she wasn’t part of, to a reader whose mood had been set before the first scroll.
The post she wrote reached someone. An entirely different post reached the reader. That’s what “the feed edits you” means in practice.
None of this says speech is worthless. It says this venue, used this way, by people without institutional power, is a terrible instrument for persuasion.
If you’re building an audience on the feed, a wide-open lane exists — domain speech, your expertise, the work. The problem isn’t social media. It’s handing the algorithm something heated enough to repurpose as fuel for the fire.
Rationale 3: I Have a Duty to Speak
Some of the most thoughtful people I know genuinely believe silence is complicity and that if they have an audience that listens, they also have a moral obligation to speak out.
This is how passionately some feel about it: a reader emailed me calling neutrality cowardice and actually alluding to Dante’s Inferno. He wrote:
“Dante put the uncommitted in the Vestibule of Hell – rejected by both Heaven and Hell, not even given the dignity of a name. Stand for nothing, and nothing is what you’ll become.”
The Dante analogy doesn’t fit here. Dante is writing about the eternal fate of souls, and we’re talking about writing a post about a breaking news story. Putting those two things on the same scale is how people end up convinced that staying in their expertise lane is somehow a moral failure.
I watched this play out in real time, with one prominent voice calling people either “Lions or Sheep,” depending on whether they agreed with him and “took a stand.”
I also watched firsthand what happened to the people who took that bait. Practices and reputations destroyed. Relationships that took years to build were gone in a single news cycle.
Two Reasons The Duty Argument Doesn’t Apply to You
You are not mass media.
A celebrity’s statement on a controversy might register as news for a day. Your statement on the same topic only sorts your email list into people who agree and people who don’t.
The algorithm then helpfully builds you an audience organized around that agreement, not around your practice, and six months later, you have a list that no longer buys what you actually sell.
The converted don’t need your opinion.
And the unconverted won’t grant you any special authority for offering it. That’s because people change their minds only through trusted relationships, conversations where they feel safe and unthreatened, and through experiencing consequences – not from a stranger’s carousel.
Before you hit post, ask: Is this post a direct service to the people I exist to serve? If not, it’s self-soothing in public, which people indulge in all the time on their personal feeds as private citizens. The professional role you’ve built is what makes you worth returning to, and it’s worth protecting.
The Martyrs and the Lighthouse
This “duty to speak” argument came up constantly during the pandemic. Professionals with large audiences who had never gone near politics suddenly felt a sincere obligation to speak out.
I understand the pull. For many, it felt like the most important event of their lives. For some, it genuinely was.
I remember a video I saw at the time, featuring health influencers and experts who had been kicked off social media platforms for speaking out, their faces solemn as they shared their stories of lost followers and digital exile. Each spoke with the mournful tone of martyrs, while the background music swelled to emphasize their sacrifice:
“I was kicked off Instagram three times; the first time, I lost 350,000 followers. The second time, I lost the 160,000 I’d rebuilt. The third time, I lost 50,000. And I’d do it again.”
Meanwhile, while they were busy “doing it again,” arguing with strangers and feeding the outrage machine, the audiences they used to serve went elsewhere.
When the smoke cleared, and the world found some normalcy, those who’d proudly lost started over from scratch. For a fourth time.
I wasn’t moved or inspired by that video. I was furious.
What I saw in that video wasn’t courage. It was an abdication. When you turn the camera on your own frustration instead of your client’s problems, you aren’t ‘speaking truth to power.’ You are resigning from your post.
These experts lost the authority they had spent decades building the moment they stopped being a signal their audience could count on.
By choosing to be activists on their professional feeds, these influencers walked away from the duty they were tasked with. They didn’t just lose their followers; they abandoned them.
There Is Another Path
Over the same period, I watched a few experts choose a different path. They didn’t ignore the world, but by staying focused, they became a lighthouse in the storm.
I think of one health expert who spent the entire pandemic laser-focused on his core expertise, advocating for a meat-based nutritional approach to health.
While many of his peers were busy ‘speaking out’ about politics and protesting the algorithm, he remained steadfast. His feed didn’t change. His tone didn’t shift. He didn’t offer a single opinion on the firestorms of the day, even when his peers – like crabs in a bucket – tried to pull him down, demanding to know why he wasn’t ‘taking a stand’ on X or Y.
He understood that he hadn’t been hired to be a commentator. He was hired to be a navigator, and by refusing to abdicate his post, he didn’t just survive the storm; he became the only reliable ground his audience had left to stand on.
While the ‘activist’ experts were busy losing their platforms to prove a point, he was busy helping his people get better. His audience growth during that period underscores how hungry audiences were for this kind of leadership.
The Trap of the Moral Argument
This is the trap of the ‘moral’ argument for speaking out: it mistakes your platform for a personal soapbox rather than a professional practice.
The influencers and experts I’m describing weren’t just ‘taking a stand’; they were using the moral urgency of the moment to justify retreating from the work they’d contracted with their followers to do.
They had convinced themselves that being an advocate was a higher calling than being a steady voice in the storm.
For the person on the other side of that screen – the patient or client who is terrified, confused, and looking for a path through that storm – that advocacy was indistinguishable from abandonment.
When you trade your role as an expert for the role of a commentator, you don’t gain a ‘moral’ high ground. You lose your utility.
You aren’t hired to win arguments; you are hired to be the steady ground your audience relies on. In a world that is screaming, the most radical and professional thing you can do is hold the line of your expertise.
You don’t need to be louder than the noise. You just need to be the only signal your client can actually recognize when they need to find their way home.
Rationale 4: At Least I’m Doing Something
This one doesn’t come up as often as a rationale as it does as a feeling the moment something big happens.
Might be a decision, a ruling, a statement, and you’re watching people you respect post about it.
You open a draft. You’ve been in her workshop, or read his newsletter for three years. And you think: I should say something. What kind of person says nothing right now?
That feeling is worth taking seriously, because it’s honest. Underneath most political posting from people who don’t usually post politically, there’s a sense of helplessness, and a desire to “do something.”
Something happened that feels large, wrong, and out of reach. The feed is right there.
And the feed, at least, responds.
Here’s what actually happened: you gave the platform content, and it used it to fuel the rage machine. In exchange, the platform gave you a moment of relief. That’s the transaction.
The notification arrives, the likes accumulate, and the feedback loop confirms the feeling that you acted.
Meanwhile, the thing you were upset about is still exactly where you left it. The platform got what it needed. You get a feeling that resembles having done something, which isn’t quite the same as having done it.
Posting is Not Acting
The feed is designed to blur that distinction. The platform needs you to feel that posting is participating, because participation is what keeps you on the platform. That feeling of “doing something” is not a side effect of using the feed. It’s the product.
One professor I know who felt this way during a particularly bad news week was tired of that helpless social feedback loop.
She turned off the feed for a month and started calling her state senator’s office instead — once a week, same staffer, same two issues. She told me later she felt less of the transient, momentary relief of social, but more effective. The feed rewards the feeling. It doesn’t much care about the outcome. If the conviction is real, it deserves a venue that does.
The feed is one instrument among many, and for persuasion and civic action, it is one of the worst available.
And treating silence on a feed as the equivalent of silence on a moral question confuses the platform with the principle.
Rationale 5: Not Participating is a Selfish Act
This one gets under my skin.
There’s a persistent argument among the professionally political that places social pressure and perceived obligation above your actual professional life.
The idea is that wanting to make a living is selfish. Protecting your professional relationships for the sake of your income is somehow less noble than “changing things.” The greater good should always win out over your own livelihood.
I want to push back on that. Hard.
As I pointed out earlier, most of what gets called “changing things” online is theatre, and increasingly, paid theatre. And theatre rarely changes anything or anyone.
Add to that the irony that those requesting this sacrifice of you are sometimes paid agitators, who wouldn’t give up their livelihood.
Most of This Pressure Shows Up in One of Two Ways
These folks treat a professional setting as another place where you need to register your position on something publicly, or they treat your refusal to do so as proof that you care more about “your own comfort” than about whatever the issue happens to be that week.
Either way, your professional relationships get subordinated to a demand that seems more moral than your work itself.
What does “changing things” actually look like in these moments? A post, maybe a statement in a meeting. A shared graphic and required affirmation. These are visible, low-cost moves for the person asking you to make them. They rarely change how the work gets done, how decisions get made, or where resources actually go.
After the moment passes, the same people still have to show up, meet their deadlines, and keep the lights on. The visible gesture gets counted as a contribution to the cause, and that’s where it all falls apart.
The framing that calls your refusal “selfish” only works if you first accept that the performance is the real work of change. Once you grant that, any concern for your income, your continued employment, or your ordinary working relationships starts to look like a lesser priority.
This Framing Conveniently Ignores Something Important
The daily work of providing for yourself and the people who depend on you is not a side issue. It’s not a private preference. It’s the foundation that makes any intentional contribution possible. Treating it as morally secondary only holds if you’re also willing to believe that a public gesture is more consequential than it usually is.
What’s more, the two actually don’t have to compete.
When you decline to treat every workplace interaction as a platform, you’re not choosing “comfort over change.” You’re declining to treat a low-leverage signal as the measure of how seriously you take anything. Relationships and a paycheck are the ordinary means by which most people support the people and places they actually affect in real life.
Demanding that those means be put at risk for a gesture that changes little doesn’t become more noble simply because someone else frames it as an obligation.
Rationale 6: But My Work IS Political
This one comes up a lot, especially from people in the health space. During the pandemic, because most of the experts I worked with were in the health space, suddenly it felt like everything flooded into Domain speech and nothing was off-limits.
Here’s a useful test: if you put this post on your about page tomorrow, would it make your promise more precise, or turn your offer into a campaign pamphlet?
If this is who you are at work, working with clients, then you should be able to state it in your offer — clearly, without pulling in the week’s heat, without adding a villain. Put it on your about page. Put it in the guarantee. Put it in the “who this is not for” section, where the right people can use it to find you, and the wrong ones can self-select out before they ever get in the door.
That’s the grown-up version. Not performing or disappearing. Putting the conviction where it actually does work — where the buyer agreed to meet you.
The dopamine hit of posting during a heated moment is cheap because it spends down trust you built one client at a time. If the belief belongs in the offer, put it there. If it doesn’t, it doesn’t get to use your offer’s audience as fuel.
When the answer is the latter, the post belongs to the citizen, not the expert.
Political speech belongs in the offer when four conditions are true at once. Miss one, and you’re usually off-purpose.
1. It changes who you serve on purpose. The buyer knows, before they pay, that this stance is part of the promise you made them. A financial planner who only works with clients who want to keep money out of certain industries. An expert consultant whose method is “stop performing for the algorithm, build an owned list.”
Your stance shrinks your market on purpose.
If you would be relieved to lose the people who disagree with you, that’s positioning. If you would be panicked, it’s an off-purpose diversion you haven’t admitted yet.
2. It has to show up in your work, not just in your words. A trauma therapist whose method refuses diagnosis-as-identity is making a claim about institutions. A doctor who structures cash-pay visits because they think the billing regime harms care is making a civic claim inside their product. A leadership coach who will not teach “personal brand as combat” is drawing a line that shows up in their workshops.
Compare that to any of the same practitioners quote-tweeting about a cabinet appointment. One is the work. The other is the person grabbing the work’s microphone for a hot take.
3. It is stable enough to put in the book. Offers have a half-life of years. News-cycle positions have a half-life of hours. If you would print that post in chapter one of your book and still defend it in year five, it can be part of the Frame – the way you see the problem. If you would need a footnote timestamping the post, it is weather.
Dolly’s “I love everybody, I won’t be a mascot” was book-stable. “Here is what I think of this week’s hearing” was not, which is why she refused to let interviewers put those words in her mouth.
4. You would still say it even if the post died at zero views. This is the ego filter. On-purpose speech is said because the work requires it. Off-purpose speech is said because silence feels like losing status. If a sentence needs an audience to be worth saying, it’s not serving the buyer. It is serving the poster’s need to be counted among the good.
When those four line up, the speech is not “getting political.” It’s completing a promise you’ve already made.
Rationale 7: I Don’t Care If People Leave
This is one I hear often, especially in a heated political climate. It usually sounds something like: “I don’t care if people drop off. Let them. They weren’t my audience anyway.”
Or this: “If they don’t agree with me, I don’t want to work with them.”
Here’s what I’ve noticed about these statements. “People who agree with me” was not one of your criteria while you painstakingly invested four years attracting and growing that audience.
And I rarely hear any of these statements before the posts go out. I hear them only after the speaker has been shadowbanned, lost half their audience, or been kicked off a platform entirely. The bravery arrives once the damage is done.
That timing matters, because it tells you what kind of statement these actually are.
Strategy vs. Story
There is a real version of “let them go” – and it is one of the more powerful moves an Indie-expert can make. But you make that call before you post, not in the story you build after the numbers arrive.
When you are values-driven and know exactly who you are, you’ve built your offer around that clarity, and any attrition is an intentional feature of your positioning – something you chose on purpose, in advance. That’s strategy.
The version I hear after the shadowban is something else. It’s the story you tell yourself about an outcome you didn’t choose. That’s not positioning. That’s cope disguised as conviction.
The difference is easy to test. Revisit the question I asked in the last rationale: if you would be relieved to lose the people who disagree with your stance, that is positioning.
If you would be panicked, it was an off-purpose diversion you hadn’t admitted to yet. Ask yourself which one you actually felt – before you hit publish, not after the numbers come in.
Here’s the invisible tax: Shadowbanning doesn’t announce itself. The algorithm silently throttles your reach – fewer impressions, fewer recommendations, and a slower feed that stops showing your work to new people.
You’ll Rarely Even Know It’s Happening
When experts decide they’ve been shadowbanned or censored, that’s when I suggest slowing down. You’re on someone else’s platform. They owe no one an audience. They write the rules; they’re usually upfront about them (don’t cost the advertisers their audience), and starting with what you may have written that got you flagged is always a more useful starting point than the conspiracy one.
The Illusion of “Them”
There’s a second problem with the story in Rationale Seven: you rarely know who “they” actually are. The image in your head when you say “let them go” is trolls and bots—the loudest, most hostile responders.
Your actual clients or buyers almost never announce themselves when they drift. When you celebrate the departure of “those people,” you are mostly writing off a projection, not a person.
What fills that gap is a story you tell yourself: “The people who left weren’t my people anyway.” “I’m being suppressed because I’m right.” The platform mechanics become evidence of your righteousness, which is exactly the kind of reasoning that keeps you from noticing the actual cost.
There’s also a contradiction for anyone in the people-changing business. When you decide that someone who disagrees with you on this one issue can’t benefit from what you do, you’re treating a belief as a fixed characteristic — which is the kind of thinking your work is supposed to interrupt.
One position on one issue is not the whole person. People change. And if that’s what your practice is about, writing someone off on a single interaction is the most un-expert thing you can do.
To sum this up: Chosen attrition is a strategy. Surprised attrition with a good explanation is not. The question worth thinking about before you post isn’t “will I be okay if people leave?” It’s “am I choosing this, or will I be explaining it later?”
From the perspective of our framework (from the first part of this series), this is a Relational failure, not a positioning move. The audience signed up for a particular relationship with you. Treating attrition as a win, after the fact, misreads what broke — and what it cost.
Seven rationales. Each one is an honest answer to the same underlying feeling: I have a conviction, and silence feels like losing. The research doesn’t invalidate that feeling, but it is clear about the futility of using the feed as a venue.
Part 3 of this series is about where the conviction belongs; the difference between political conviction and personal values; what actually does move the needle; and a checklist for moments when the conviction is real, the feeling is hot, and the feed is right there.

Leave a Reply