Next time you catch yourself thinking your topic’s been done – that someone else got there first and said it better – go to your favorite streaming service and type in: The Carpenters – Ticket to Ride.
Then, listen to the Beatles’ 1965 original, if it’s been a while.
Same song. Same words. Completely different records.
The Beatles’ version is mid-tempo, with insistent guitar and Lennon half-smirking through the breakup lyrics.
The Carpenters slowed it into a piano-and-strings ballad. Karen’s voice is intimate and unhurried, letting the heartbreak resonate, and it closes on the repeated line: “Think I’m gonna be sad.”
The Carpenters worked with the raw material and went somewhere the original never did.
There are plenty of examples of this, and each one surprised us, not because the song was new, but because the perspective was.
Your version of a topic does the same thing. It doesn’t need to be the first or the definitive one. It just needs to be yours.
Your topics aren’t exhausted. You just haven’t written your version yet.
For further proof, look no further than the holiday playlist that reappears every November and is played across every public space and streaming platform.
The Most Recycled Playlist in the World Is a Content Strategy Master Class
We’re not going to find another time of year when the same 200 songs are played 24/7, and the odds are good that by the end of the season you will have heard them all several times.
Most of those songs slide past without registering. Some of them invite you to sing along. And a few make you stop mid-aisle and pull out your phone to find out who that was.
That difference comes down to what the artist did with the song.
A playlist this saturated, heard this many times, is about as controlled a laboratory as you’ll find for understanding how expert content actually works.
That unavoidable repetition maps almost perfectly onto the four types of expert content – explaining exactly why some of it stops you for a deeper read, and why most of it evaporates.
Four types of artists show up in most playlists, and they mirror the four types of expert content in your social feeds and Google search results.
Expert Content Type One: The Background Artist
You know this music. It’s everywhere.
These are the faithfully rendered, technically accurate, and pleasantly produced versions of holiday classics piped into shopping malls and Shopify playlists from Thanksgiving through New Year’s.
Nothing wrong with them – they’re usually listenable. But can you name who sang any of the last five holiday songs you heard?
Probably not. And it doesn’t matter. That’s the point.
This is elevator music. It often comes from artists recording the obligatory Christmas album to fulfill a contract. It exists to fill space, not to be heard.
The Background Artist in Your Search Results
Background Artist is where most experts start writing content. It’s the writing you do while uncovering your voice and your point of view, and that unique measure of “you” that draws people to what you write and makes them come back for more.
Plenty of experts never planned on staying here, but no one ever offered them an alternative. So, their writing is perfectly serviceable. But does it reach an audience?
Many of the experts I work with fall back on the same academic habits they picked up in school, which served them well on campus. They write dispassionately, carefully hedging while using insider jargon. The problem is that those same habits create distance from the readers they most want to reach — not through any lack of care, but because no one ever showed them how to write for a different audience.
Usually, you’re writing to a lay audience that doesn’t yet fully understand your specialized expertise — and increasingly, audiences have a lot less patience for dry, academic content packed with jargon.
The Content Mindset That Keeps You Invisible
Some experts treat content as an obligatory chore of the digital age: a box to check off before moving on to the “real” work. The content exists because it’s supposed to exist, not because there’s anything particular to say. The result, predictably, is content that sounds like everything else in the feed.
To be fair, few artists set out to make elevator music, and most experts writing the content equivalent don’t realize that’s what they’ve made.
This is where the Beatles/Carpenters comparison we opened with turns personal — because your topics work exactly the same way.
Ten health experts can write about the same topic and disappear into the feed because they all write from the same angle, with the same perspective and with little variation.
They’ve become “background content” because the feed is so saturated with the same stuff and their content has no voice, no perspective, and no reason for anyone to come back specifically for them.
Then an expert comes along and writes about the same topics as the first ten, but with a fresh perspective, a new angle, and a dash of personality and point of view. The topics may be the same, but he’s reinvented a classic topic, making it fresh and relevant.
Reinvention Has Never Mattered More
Now look at your corner of the internet. Those using AI tools to post generic content on their behalf may already be the Spotify playlist – and not even know it. Beautifully formatted articles. Solid grammar. Recognizable topics, covered in the same way as everyone else.
And the same problem, now at scale: no voice or perspective, and now competing with machines that can produce this indefinitely.
You’ve seen their sites and their feeds. You know the ones: Interchangeable experts offering interchangeable advice. Slick, answer-lite content that gets you in and out without ever giving you anything to grasp.
This should concern the expert who counted on background content to build their name. AI is generating this type of content faster than any human, at any volume, for nearly nothing.
That category of content was never a reliable way to build, but now it’s not even a category. It’s a function – one that’s being automated in real time.
AI is very good at aggregating, finding the center, and delivering the safe, consensus version of any idea. That’s not a flaw in the technology — it’s what it’s designed to do.
The good news? Your voice and point of view live well outside that mediated center — and always will.
That’s your opportunity. The next three Expert Content types are where your voice takes shape and finds its place.
Expert Content Type Two: The Curator
I was king of mix tapes. Every friend and loved one received at least one, usually several. I couldn’t help myself: so much great music to share, and the lyrics were the poetry I often couldn’t write myself.
That instinct – to select, to sequence, to share with a point of view – turns out to have a name.
Same with your favorite Spotify playlist. Those curators didn’t write those songs. They didn’t perform them. But their selection, their sequencing, their editorial judgment about what belongs next to what – that is a distinctive creative act. Pull up someone else’s playlist, and it feels completely different, even when half the songs overlap.
The Curator’s fingerprint is found in the curation itself.
What This Looks Like In Your Content
In content terms, these are the Indie-experts who read widely and synthesize well. They don’t necessarily generate new research, but they read studies, track emerging conversations in their field, and connect the dots their audience doesn’t have time to. Their content says: I read this, and this, and this – and here’s what that actually means for you.
The Curator’s voice is editorial. It’s opinionated. It says: out of everything happening in this field right now, here’s what’s worth your attention, and here’s why. Its creation requires what’s missing in much of the conversation around AI content: judgment.
Expert Content Type Three: The Innovator
We all know songs that have been reinterpreted in memorable ways. You no doubt have your favorites.
The Innovator doesn’t write a new song. She takes the existing material – the one everyone knows, the one everyone assumes is done – and finds the version inside it that no one else heard.
The Innovator at Work
When writing content, the Innovator starts where anyone seriously engaged in their field would: the studies or frameworks already circulating. A serious student could find the same sources.
What that student won’t find is the connection the Innovator made between those sources — the unique perspective on familiar material that only she saw.
You arrive at her content knowing something about the topic, and leave with a question you hadn’t thought to ask.
Expert Content Type Four: The Original
What an Original and an Innovator share is the same starting point: everything that influenced them. The Beatles were devoted students of Chuck Berry and Buddy Holly before they were the Beatles.
The Originals you’ve loved were once students who borrowed and synthesized what came before. The difference is what happened to those influences once the Original got hold of them.
With an Innovator, you can still hear echoes of Stairway to Heaven, no matter how much it’s been rearranged.
With an Original, the source material is thoroughly deconstructed and reassembled. Brian Wilson absorbed Phil Spector’s Wall of Sound so completely that Good Vibrations doesn’t sound like an influence — it sounds like an invention.
When creating your body of work, the shift to Original happens when you are the source material.
Nobody else has access to the frameworks you built from your failures and breakthroughs, or the patterns you kept seeing in your work. Those aren’t things you pulled from a database.
And that’s the vantage point no competitor can copy, and no AI can replicate: not what you learned, but what it cost you to learn it.
The question isn’t whether your ideas are unprecedented – it’s whether your perspective, your synthesis, your angle of entry is yours alone.
Most of the writers I’d call Originals didn’t start there. The path almost always runs through Curation and Innovation first.
Curiosity is the on-ramp; start there. Your curiosity is the match, and your experience is the fuel. That’s the vantage point that makes your work impossible to replicate.
Which One Are You Building Toward?
The playlist has room for all four types. The Background Artists fill the silence. The Curators bring you pure signal, without the hours of searching. The Innovators give us something to remember. And the Originals, when they get it right, give us something that lasts.
Here’s what matters: The distance between these four isn’t talent. It’s a decision.
In your field – in health, in coaching, in expert practice – the ladder runs in exactly that order, too. Background Artist is for experts still finding their voice. Curator is the first rung. Innovator is the next. And Original is the goal that makes the ladder worth climbing.
The real question isn’t which role you’re filling right now. It’s which one you’re willing to build toward.
Ticket to Ride was written in 1965. The Carpenters heard it and, four years later, found something entirely new inside it. Someone is going to do the same thing to your corner of the field.
The only question is whether that someone is you.

Leave a Reply